Sometimes I feel like I can’t share my story. Because I’m a thin, white, cisgender, able-bodied, financially secure woman — living in a really complex world right now — to say the least.
I hold an enormous amount of privilege. And as a weight-inclusive, fat-positive, Health At Every Size-aligned dietitian and body image coach, I never want my story to take up space that belongs to people whose bodies are more marginalized than mine.
But I’ve realized something: Acknowledging my privilege doesn’t require me to erase my pain. Multiple things can be true. I have struggled deeply with food, exercise, health, and my body. And I have been protected by thin privilege throughout that struggle. Both are true. I’ve shared glimpses of my story before, but I think I’m finally ready to say the hard parts out loud.
I was praised when I was the least healthy I had ever been.
There was a period of my life when I was in one of the smallest bodies I had ever lived in. And people thought I looked so healthy. I tracked my calories and macros. I rarely missed a workout. I stepped on the scale constantly to make sure I was still “okay.”
I tracked every bite of food. I fixated on my workouts and exercised when my body was begging me to rest. From the outside, I probably looked like the picture of health: thin, disciplined, active, strong. Inside? I was miserable. I was exhausted. I was obsessed with food.
My brain was constantly calculating, planning, monitoring, checking, compensating. I was lonely. I was isolated. My world had become incredibly small. And I was missing my own life. But nobody seemed worried about me. People praised me. Because my behaviors were producing a body our culture associates with health.
And every compliment reinforced the same message: I guess this is what I’m supposed to do to be healthy. That’s one of the most dangerous things about disordered eating. Sometimes it doesn’t look like illness. Sometimes it looks like “discipline.” Sometimes it looks like “wellness.”
Sometimes it looks like someone who “takes really good care of herself.” Sometimes it gets complimented. And I didn’t know what I was experiencing wasn’t normal. Nobody around me was talking about the mental cost of pursuing health this way. So I didn’t talk about it either.
The more I tried to control my health, the more out of control I felt.
Eventually, I couldn’t keep doing it. I knew I needed to heal. Not just physically. Mentally. Emotionally. Socially. I needed my life back. And no amount of dieting, tracking, exercising, or weight loss was going to give that to me. Healing meant doing something terrifying: letting go of control.
I tracked less. I let go of food rules. I exercised less. I rested more. I ate more. I listened to my body instead of constantly trying to override it. And yes — my body changed. I gained weight. At that point in my healing, that’s what my body needed to do.
And it was fucking hard. Buying bigger clothes was hard. Trying something on and realizing it no longer fit was gut-wrenching. Knowing intellectually that bodies change didn’t magically make me immune to everything I had been taught about what it meant for my body to get bigger.
But something else was happening at the same time. I was getting healthier. My mind was quieter. My body felt less stressed. I had fewer aches and pains. I had more energy. More capacity. My labs improved. My stress decreased. Food stopped taking up every corner of my brain.
My body got bigger for a while, and my life got bigger with it. That changed the way I understood health forever.
And then came the biggest mindfuck of all.
Eventually, my body got smaller again. Except this time, I wasn’t trying to make it smaller. I wasn’t dieting. I wasn’t tracking. I wasn’t trying to earn food through exercise. I wasn’t pursuing weight loss. I was nourishing my body. Resting it. Listening to it.
Respecting it. Finding safety in it. And a significant part of that body change happened after I finally started taking medication to support my mental and emotional health instead of trying to white-knuckle it alone. Weight loss happened to be an unintended effect. And weirdly?
Losing weight scared me. Because I had worked so hard to get out of the cycle where a smaller body automatically meant I was doing something right. I didn’t want weight loss to become another invitation back into obsession.
Which taught me another uncomfortable lesson about body image healing: You don’t get to know what your body is going to do. That’s scary as fuck. Healing your relationship with your body isn’t a promise that you’ll learn to love your body and then it will conveniently become the size you wanted it to be all along.
Your body might get smaller. It might get bigger. It might stay exactly where it is. It might change repeatedly throughout your life. The work is learning that your body does not have to remain one particular size for you to continue treating it with dignity.
And we live in a culture that makes that incredibly difficult.
We have been taught there is one acceptable direction for a body to change.
Smaller. If your body gets smaller, we celebrate. If your body gets bigger, we panic. And somewhere along the way, we started calling that health. But if our definition of health begins and ends with what someone’s physical body looks like, we’ve already lost the plot.
And if we say mental and emotional health matter — until supporting someone’s mental and emotional health might result in weight gain — we’ve also lost the plot. Health cannot require you to destroy one part of yourself to optimize another.
And this is one of my biggest concerns about the current GLP-1 era. This isn’t about being anti-medication or anti-health. I’m not either one of those things. It’s about being unwilling to return to a culture of thinness at all costs simply because we have new tools capable of changing body weight.
Because people are hurting. And the people who will experience the greatest consequences aren’t people who look like me.
This is where my privilege matters.
I struggled with disordered eating in a thin body. That mattered. It hurt. It changed me. And I still had thin privilege. Healthcare providers didn’t look at my body and automatically prescribe weight loss. I wasn’t routinely treated as though my body itself was the problem that needed to be solved.
My eating and exercise behaviors could hide behind the social acceptability of my body size. People praised behaviors in me that may have been viewed very differently in another body. That’s why telling my story can never mean pretending my experience is equivalent to the experiences of people living in larger bodies.
It isn’t. But my experience taught me how incredibly easy it is for harmful behaviors to masquerade as health when weight loss is occurring. And that’s something I desperately want healthcare providers to understand. Because people in larger bodies can have eating disorders. People in larger bodies can be restricting.
They can be terrified of food. They can be compulsively exercising. They can be bingeing. They can be malnourished. They can be experiencing profound psychological distress around food and their bodies.
And if the only thing we see when we look at them is a BMI that needs to come down, we can miss all of it.
That’s why I do this work.
I didn’t heal so I could become the perfect example of recovery. I healed so I could live. And now I want to use what I’ve learned — alongside my clinical training and continued learning from people whose lived experiences are different from mine — to advocate for something better.
Healthcare where someone’s relationship with food matters. Where mental health matters. Where emotional health matters. Where social connection matters. Where quality of life matters. Where eating disorder symptoms matter regardless of someone’s BMI. Where providers are willing to examine their own internalized weight stigma and anti-fat bias.
That doesn’t mean every doctor is intentionally harming patients. Bias doesn’t require malicious intent. A provider can care deeply about their patients and still hold beliefs they’ve never been asked to examine.
That’s where the work is. We have to be willing to learn. And once we know better, we have a responsibility to do better.
I also think both “sides” have work to do.
The eating disorder space has work to do. The weight loss space has work to do. Weight inclusive healthcare has work to do. This cannot keep being an either/or conversation. We should be able to talk critically about the harms of weight-centric medicine without pretending every intervention involving weight is inherently evil.
We should be able to acknowledge the realities of eating disorders without centering only thin, white, affluent bodies. We should be able to talk about GLP-1 medications without either demonizing them or pretending intentional weight loss is psychologically neutral. We should be able to care about cardiometabolic health and eating disorder risk.
We should be able to hold physical health, mental health, emotional health, autonomy, access, stigma, socioeconomic circumstances, trauma, and quality of life in the same conversation. That’s what healthcare should be capable of doing.
It’s not either/or. It’s both/and. And our patients deserve clinicians willing to sit inside that discomfort, nuance, and complexity.
So I’m going to start telling my story.
I’ve been afraid that talking about my own experience would somehow make me less credible as a weight-inclusive, fat-positive dietitian. I’m beginning to believe the opposite.
My story is part of why I refuse to reduce health to body size. I know what it feels like to look “healthy” while quietly falling apart. I know what it feels like to have your body change while you’re healing.
I know how terrifying it can be to stop controlling your body when you’ve been taught that controlling it is the responsible thing to do.
And I also know that my privilege shaped every part of that experience. Both things are true. My privilege is real. My struggle was real. One does not erase the other. My story isn’t everyone’s story. It isn’t meant to be. It’s mine. And I’m ready to start sharing more of it.
Because I believe in a version of healthcare where you don’t have to lose yourself in the pursuit of health. Where your provider sees more than the BMI listed in your chart. Where your body isn’t an agenda before you’ve even opened your mouth. Where you’re treated as a whole human being — with dignity, respect, curiosity, and autonomy.
And where getting “healthier” doesn’t require your life to become smaller. Because sometimes the healthiest thing you can do is stop shrinking your life in an attempt to shrink your body.
If this resonates, you can explore working with me, read about coping with body changes, or find more conversations on Chats with Mack.